Book Review Communism/Marxism/Maoism Elizabeth Bentley Espionage/"Intelligence" Ethel Rosenberg Fred Rose History HUAC Lauren Bacall McCarthyism News

Whittaker Chambers or Alger Hiss: Who’s the Real Traitor?

Whittaker Chambers or Alger Hiss: Who's the Real Traitor?

Although #1 on the New York Occasions Bestseller record for 13 weeks in 1952, beloved of William Buckley and Ronald Reagan (“So long as humanity speaks of advantage and goals of freedom, the life and writings of Whittaker Chambers will ennoble and encourage.”), despite being hailed as “one of the dozen or so indispensable books of the century” (George Will), Witness shortly disappeared from our collective consciousness. We keep in mind its most well-known victim, Alger Hiss, as a nice man who was mercilessly hounded, the prelude to the McCarthy purges of the 1950s, a ugly stain on US historical past.

Chambers was a gifted writer, penning in style brief stories in the New Plenty in 1931, a full time editor and journalist at Time. His autobiography is filled with details of each side of the so-called treachery of the occasions, and Chambers’ own ruminations about love and dying and the entire rattling thing. It swings from over-the-top self-righteousness to self-abnegation, maniacal zeal as a communist, then as a spy, then as self-proclaimed Mr Right, and woe to anyone standing in the best way of his mission to Save the World from Communism.

Like his closeted father, his uncle and brother, all of whom committed suicide, he was possessed by a demon, which drove him to an early grave, working 36-hour days at Time within the 1940s, first doing guide critiques, then modifying the overseas news web page (till he had his second heart attack), then back to books. His fellow journalists resented his new-found conservative attacks on their liberal New Vendor mindset, seeing all of them as commie dupes. He immortalized himself destroying the careers of ‘good guys’, Alger Hiss and Harry Dexter White amongst many others, for his or her idealistic sins. He turned a born-again Quaker, though, like fellow Quaker Richard Nixon, he still believed in ‘simply wars’ towards commies.


His worldview was apocalyptic, first by means of pink lenses, then puritan. Evil is the central drawback of human life. The 2 opposing worldviews: man as flawed/ sinful (Christianity) vs man nearly as good/ perfectable (enlightenment, liberalism -> communism).

Alger Hiss

Alger Hiss

We keep in mind only Alger Hiss as Chambers’ victim, but Hiss acquired off lucky. Chambers exposed Harry Dexter White (1892–1948), the senior American official at the 1944 Bretton Woods conference that established the postwar economic order, as a spy. White died of a heart assault shortly after HUAC hearings in 1948.

White and Keynes at Bretton Woods

Hiss was sentenced to five years’ imprisonment in 1950 (for perjury, as his ‘crimes’ have been from 1938) serving solely three years and eight months. While in jail, Hiss acted as a volunteer lawyer, adviser, and tutor for many of his fellow inmates. Disbarred, he served as a lowly clerk until in 1975, he was readmitted to the Massachusetts bar, the first time a convicted felon was reinstated. The contents of the ‘pumpkin papers’ have been finally revealed as of no significance to state security.

White and Keynes at Bretton Woods

Hiss insisted to the top he was harmless. Witness definitely reveals Chambers and Hiss as shut buddies for so long as Chambers remained in the celebration. What sort of spy was White? “The economics White advocated have been hardly Marxist. They have been by this time what can be described as completely Keynesian … As for White’s domestic politics, these have been mainstream New Deal progressive, and there is no proof that he admired communism as a political ideology. White’s daughters nonetheless strongly keep his innocence. Chambers crucified Hiss and White merely for eager to deal with the Soviets as what they have been — allies, pals.


Despite his protestations of preventing evil, what Chambers really was after was personal revenge. He had believed and found his religion was betrayed by Stalin’s crimes, which he now believed included wanting WWIII and world conquest, although we should take his phrase, as there isn’t a proof of this in Chambers’ Witness (or anyplace else, to my information, beyond rhetorical thrives). He quotes his own draft Time editorial ‘Ghosts on the roof’ concerning the Yalta convention in 1945, where he portrayed the Soviet Union and US as ‘jet planes’ flying in the direction of one another, the place one has to destroy different. This digital declaration of conflict was removed earlier than it was revealed, although the brand new Chilly Struggle theme remained.

His new Christian religion armed him for his heretical/ saintly battle towards communists, despite his Time colleagues, who have been all New Dealers driving high on the crest of WWII, when the Soviets have been our pals. He made the transition from communist militant to communist heretic to Christian saint, all the time the mantra: ‘how might one man be right when so many say he’s mistaken?’. All the time the self-proclaimed martyr, pressured to resign from Time, driving himself to an early dying.

His unique identify was Vivian, his father an artist, a father in identify only, so, in fact, he was bullied, a lonely youngster. He ran away from residence and located work tearing up road automotive tracks for a couple of months, his stint with the proletariat. Born in 1901, he was 16 when the Russian revolution electrified the capitalist world, and like idealistic youth at the time, he searched out these allied with it. He tried the Webbs, Fabian socialism,  but ‘there was no life there. The reek of life was missing.’ To remake the world, socialism involved violent wrestle to get and hold energy.

Should you simply read the first 300 pages of Witness, you’ll be able to come away believing, like he did (but in his case, later with horror), that communism will triumph, despite the various horrors perpetrated within the identify of the revolution beneath Stalin.

He explains three influences on him in his testimony to the grand jury’s query ‘what does it mean to be a communist’: the Cheka founder Dzerzhinsky, who cleaned latrines in his Warsaw prison for instance to these much less developed, the German Jew Eugene Levine, leader of the 1918-9 Bavarian Soviet Republic, when sentenced to dying, who advised his executioner a communist is ‘all the time underneath sentence of dying’, and the Russian Narodnik Kalyaev/ Sazonov, who burned himself alive as protest towards flogging.

Witness is an indictment of each great faiths of our occasions, capitalism (sorry, ‘freedom’) and communism. Both are doomed. WWI led to the Russian revolution. WWII has led to the last stage of the crisis with the rise of communism as a world energy. Here, warfare led to revolution. Now it’s the reverse: revolution will result in WWIII, launched by the communists to take management of the world. Wait a minute. Presumably capitalism/ freedom led to WWI and WWII. So now it’s communism resulting in WWIII? Chambers sketched out the doubtful state of affairs that might dominate the US zeitgeist for the subsequent half century, and which continues as we speak in the ‘warfare on terror’, now expanded to include Islam. It seems struggle is alive and nicely, sans communism, and is the result of capitalism/ freedom.

We should all the time be on guard, as it’s straightforward ‘to fall into the communist lure: The vision evokes, the disaster impels.’ Communism gives two powerful certainties: a cause to stay and die. But this belies ‘a shallowness of thought, and leads to incalculable mischief in motion.’ Although his argument is a pox on each houses, he retreats to the safety of the satan he knew first because the lesser of two evils, and exhorts us to hunt salvation in religion, as the mistake was ‘man without god.’ One might never be an entire man with out god. That is the fatal deficiency at the root of all of the troubles of recent man.

Chambers literally thanks the Lord for delivering him from evil. He noticed the sunshine. Breaking with communism was a spiritual expertise, as certainly it was for other renegades like him. Elizabeth Bentley went by means of an analogous life journey, turning into much more central to HUAC’s work, to the purpose that she turned a full-time paid informer for the FBI. In 1948, like Chambers and Soviet defector Krivitsky, she has a religious awakening, turning into a Roman Catholic. She was incessantly invited to lecture on the Communist menace by Catholic teams completely satisfied to pay her $300 charge. Krivitsky instantly was (presumably) murdered in 1939 earlier than he might be baptized Episcopalian.

Chambers was convinced communism would triumph, explaining to his wife: we are leaving the profitable world for the dropping one. It is tough to take this significantly, given his litany of bungling, both petty and epic, of communists throughout the period. He heard concerning the Ukrainian famine within the early 30s, he knew first hand of the devastating purges, the Spanish civil conflict (i.e., the uncivil warfare of the Stalinists towards the Trotskyists there), the rejection by the Comintern of a standard front with social democrats in Germany in 1929, allowing Hitler to move simply into power.

This motion was poised to overcome the world? He informed Hiss of his doubts a number of days earlier than Christmas in 1938, simply earlier than breaking with the social gathering. Hiss informed him this was simply ‘psychological masturbation’. Hiss knew where the actual hazard to the world lay.

Hiss forgave Chambers his doubts (he little question shared them) and needed to remain buddies, giving Chambers a present for his daughter whilst Chambers was telling him he was completed with communism. As Chambers was getting ready to rat on someone who seemed to be his closest pal at the time, this sweet gesture brought tears to his eyes. Chambers was a hopeless romantic who fell out of affection, misplaced his religion, sought revenge for its betrayal of him, and subconsciously drove himself to an early grave, an extended drawn out suicide, a household trait.

Chambers’ accusations do have the ring of fact, but it is a personal vindictive fact, which ran roughshod over others’ lives in the cause of Chambers’ personal mission to save lots of the world. He understands that communism is the logical conclusion of the enlightenment, liberalism, ‘Edwardian gluttonous pursuit of delight, secular good works, and progress,’ but prefers staying on the degree of gluttonous pursuit.

The pumpkin legacy

Chambers and his acolyte McCarthy did their greatest to destroy the most effective of American life, the New Sellers with their ideals and openness to ‘secular good works’ without the gluttony. I might hazard that he did just as much, no, more harm than Stalin’s very evil purging and hapless cat-and-mouse espionage. However Stalin’s purging was primarily of Russian communists or suspected Soviet plotters. I can’t consider one occasion of real injury carried out to the West by Soviet spying. The Soviets have been sure to crack the atom in any case, and, the earlier the better, given the anti-communist hysteria, when even Bertrand Russell toyed with the thought of a fast nuclear struggle before the Soviets had recovered from WWII.

In reality, Soviet espionage was much more benign than that of the US. The CIA and others parachuted defectors behind ‘enemy strains’ to sabotage business, later planted pc viruses into gear the Soviets have been importing, poisoned progressive thought via media management. Proof of this is found within the so-called Mitrokhin Archives. KGB Main Vasili Mitrokhin was for 30 years KGB archivist in overseas intelligence, and brought each conceivable secret when he defected to Britain in 1992.

Christopher Andrew’s Sword and the Defend (1992) and The KGB and the Battle for the Third World (2005), based mostly on the archives show pathetically little when it comes to subversion and no overarching plan to invade anyplace. Regardless of his anticommunist bias, Andrew exhibits that the KGB did little with the knowledge it collected, which principally concerned know-how acquisition, and which exhibits the reactive nature of Soviet undercover work—attempts to uncover sabotage by the West, use of blackmail to guard Soviet sources.

Canada’s most celebrated Soviet spy was Fred Rose, Canada’s one and solely communist MP. In 1945, when the Soviet Union was branded as Canada’s enemy, this led to the arrest of Rose and denial of his parliamentary immunity, when he was discovered responsible of conspiring to show over details about the explosive RDX44 to the Soviets. The Soviet defector Gouzenko had stolen paperwork from the Soviet embassy, and alleged that Rose was leading a spy ring of up to 20 Soviet spies.

He was never allowed to clear his identify. Rose didn’t see sharing RDX info at the time as spying, as the Soviets have been allies, doing a lot of the preventing towards the Nazis, but he was shortly convicted. When launched, his well being broken, abandoned by his wife while in jail, he was unable to work, hounded by the RCMP, and eventually emigrated to Poland. In later years, Rose admitted his error, saying, “I made one mistake in my life and I paid for it,” but he was denied the prospect to clear his identify of spying, as his Canadian citizenship was revoked in 1957, and his attraction was denied. Too late to matter, in 1958 Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Ellen Fairclough amended the Citizenship Act with the “Fred Rose amendment” in order that such a removing of Canadian citizenship might by no means happen once more.

“The horror of treason is sin towards the spirit,” Chambers wrote in reviewing Rebecca West’s The Which means of Treason for Time in 1947 (which, he boasts was read by ‘one million kind of’). However isn’t that what Chambers did? Hiss (type of) betrayed (within the interests of world peace). However Chambers too betrayed. He betrayed his buddies, and for what? Imperialism?

What about Forster’s “If I had to choose between betraying my country and betraying my pal I hope I should have the center to betray my nation”? Especially if ‘my nation’ is doing nasty things.

The muck of McCarthyism endures in our collective memory. Chambers’ recounting of his HUAC testimony is, as he places it, comedy. The committee members (together with Nixon who turned his ‘valued pal’) have been the uncouth, undignified, ungrammatical, impolite and ruthless, as no respectable members of congress needed to serve on it. They have been virtually uniformly bigotted, emphasizing Jewish names when calling and interrogating witnesses. The pictures we keep in mind, if any, are of Lauren Bacall and others marching in protest on the blacklisting and jailing of actors.

It’s onerous to not pity Chambers, who noticed himself as testifying for something, relatively than towards people who have been once his intimate pals, that’s, he was blind to the harm he was doing to them. The HUAC media farce couldn’t help however portray him as the dangerous man, even as the Chilly Warfare clouds have been gathering. These ‘witnessing’ the Hiss trials didn’t actually care much about microfiche spools in pumpkins (although that was entertaining). They have been fascinated, appalled by fat, pompous Whittaker’s tattling on, betraying his good-looking, mental good friend Alger, culminating in his sensational interview on Meet the Press in 1948, ‘a savage assault with little restraint or decency,’ ‘fun for the boys, demise for the frogs.’ How might he stoop to this sordid enterprise? To what end?

He admits that he was ‘bringing break on the lives of so many people and … would never again really have the ability to reside with myself.’ ‘The penalty is a type of dying, most dangerous if a man must go on dwelling. He admits his witnessing ‘destroyed himself to make his witness.’ Hey, Whittaker, keep in mind Stalin’s ‘you must break eggs to make an omelette’?

Bacall and Bogarte and other stars battle HUAC

Bacall, Bogart and other stars battle HUAC

He bemoans ‘the demise of spiritual religion’, and takes shelter in Quakerism, but nobody was listening. All they heard is the ugly HUAC clatter. Watched their beloved Hollywood stars like John Garfield, good guys like White, dying of coronary heart attacks as humiliated martyrs. My heroes are those courageous sufficient to protest on the danger of their very own careers (Lauren Bacall, Katherine Hepburn, Spencer Tracey, Humphrey Bogart….). The listing of fantastic People who stood as much as the anti-communist hysterics like Whittaker Chambers is lengthy, and will probably be remembered lengthy after Chambers et al are consigned to the dustbin of historical past.

Spydom’s legacy

Ethel Rosenberg

Whether or not or not Hiss et al have been spiritual, whether or not they ‘sinned’ by breaking the regulation, they showed much more ‘spirit’ than newly christianized Chambers and Bentley. The victims have been slowly rehabilitated beginning within the 1960s with Dalton Trumbo brazenly credited with the screenplay of Spartacus (1960). In 2015, New York City Council issued a proclamation stating that “the federal government wrongfully executed Ethel Rosenberg,” and Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer formally recognized, “the injustice suffered by Ethel Rosenberg and her household,” and declared her birthday, September 28, “Ethel Rosenberg Day of Justice in the Borough of Manhattan.” In March 2016, Michael and Robert (by way of the Rosenberg Fund for Youngsters) launched a petition marketing campaign calling on President Obama to formally exonerate their mom. 60 Minutes introduced the story of the Rosenberg youngsters and their quest for justice.

Whereas Chambers was loudly lauded in his 1961 obits, Bentley (whose victims numbered 80) was handed over. Already by the 1960s, individuals have been uninterested in the spy mania, and rightly, because the Soviet spies have been (misguided?) idealists, every one a personal tragedy, shot down by traitors-to-the-cause. Few apart from the Reagans and Buckleys remembers Chambers or Bentley et al as noble patriots, rightly, as they have been (excuse me) rats escaping/ scuttling their ship, betraying their associates. It appears Hiss really was on Soviet spy lists, as revealed when archives have been opened after 1991. Whether or not he was a ‘card-carrying communist’ and lied, I don’t know and don’t care.

I do know that such spies as Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, Rudolph Abel and Kim Philby at the moment are admired and increasingly honoured for his or her idealism and braveness. They spied within the pursuits of humanity, towards imperialism. I’m with them. Eat cake, Whittaker.

Witness was dusted off for its 50th anniversary in 2002, with a foreword by William F Buckley, who recollects that only two years after its publication ‘virtually complete silence had closed in on him.’ In his foreword, Robert Novak, counting on Hungarian archives, harrumphs: So, the case is closed. Hiss was a liar, spy and traitor. But these inveterate Cold Warriors are improper on all counts: communism was not the all-powerful ogre intent on warfare and conquest, it was improper to betray you buddies for believing what you did and then didn’t.

Chambers’ ‘valued pal’, Nixon, made detente with the evil commies his biggest legacy. As communism mellowed, it seems Christianity and communism are reconcilable in any case.

As the purple scare and blacklist unravelled within the 1950s, the journalist who led the expose of Chambers in 1948, David Sentner, went on to rearrange a go to by William Hearst Jr with Khrushchev in 1956, which gained a Pulitzer Prize, leaving Chambers’ plans to orchestrate the destruction of the communist ‘jet aircraft’ in shambles.

So the place is Chambers/ Bentley’s legacy? Down there in Dante’s Ninth Circle—the “lowest, blackest, and farthest from Heaven”—with real American traitors like Jonathan Pollard (who gave away a lot of real secrets and techniques) sentenced to life in 1987, granted Israeli citizenship in 1995, who regardless of Israeli pleas/ whining, continues to be underneath house arrest after 28 years in prison. Now there’s an actual traitor — for all however the Israelis, who paint murals and identify buildings (in east Jerusalem) in his honour.